[2023 PICKS] The Best Boutique Hotels in Cape May, NJ

The best boutique hotels in Cape May place you in some of the most idyllic locations in New Jersey.

Cape May, located on the southern tip of New Jersey, is a popular travel destination known for its Victorian-style architecture, beautiful beaches, and rich history. The town boasts a thriving arts and culture scene, as well as a variety of outdoor activities, making it a perfect destination for families, couples, and solo travelers.

Visitors can explore the historic district, stroll along the beach, and enjoy the local seafood cuisine. With its charming atmosphere, Cape May is a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, offering a relaxed and rejuvenating experience.

We hand-picked top-rated boutique hotels in Cape May to consider for your next getaway!

The 10 Best Cape May Boutique Hotels

1. Grand Hotel Cape May

8.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

For those looking for the best hotels in Cape May, NJ, the Grand Hotel of Cape May is an ideal choice. This beach-front boutique hotel offers guests a luxurious stay with access to free WiFi, on-site dining, and a range of amenities. Guests can enjoy the outdoor and indoor pool, fitness center, and laundry facilities.

Every room has a cable TV, a microwave, and a refrigerator, while private bathrooms come with free toiletries. The hotel is conveniently located 2.3 km from The Cove and 5.8 km from Sunset Beach.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

2. Angel of the Sea Bed and Breakfast

8.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Cape May, New Jersey, offers a variety of places to stay, including the Angel of the Sea Bed & Breakfast. Located just 1/2 block from the beach, this accommodation is a historic 1850 building with Victorian décor and private bathrooms. Each room features air conditioning, cable TV, complimentary toiletries, bed linens, and a fan.

Guests can enjoy a complimentary gourmet breakfast, afternoon tea service, evening wine & cheese, and antipasti reception. Free bicycle rental, beach chairs, towels, and umbrellas are provided. The Washington Street Pedestrian Mall and the beach are within 1-minute walk of the property, while Sunset Beach is 6.4 km away and Wildwood Boardwalk is 9.2 km away. Those looking for places to stay in Cape May should consider the Angel of the Sea Bed & Breakfast.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

3. Marquis De Lafayette

8.2 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Marquis De Lafayette Hotel is a luxurious boutique hotel in Cape May, New Jersey. Situated opposite the beach at Decatur Street, this luxury hotel offers stunning sea views from its balconies and terraces. Guests can enjoy the convenience of a microwave, refrigerator, and TV in their rooms, while the suites come with a sofa bed.

For those looking for a shopping experience, the Washington Street Mall is just a five-minute walk away. The Cape May Lighthouse is also 4.6 km away, and Sunset Beach is a 9-minute drive away, making this hotel an ideal choice for those looking for a beach getaway.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

4. Bedford Inn

9.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Bedford Inn is a premier Cape May boutique hotel just a block from the city’s breathtaking beaches. Guests can take advantage of the free on-site and street parking available and enjoy the convenience of being within walking distance of restaurants, shopping, and other activities.

Each of the 10 Victorian-style rooms offers individually controlled heating and air conditioning, flat-screen TVs with cable and streaming service capabilities, complimentary WiFi, and newly remodeled private bathrooms.

Our daily gourmet breakfasts feature local produce, fruit, and herbs from our garden. Refreshments and snacks are also served from 3:00-5:00 p.m. daily.

The nearest airport to The Bedford Inn is Atlantic City International, which is 70.8 km away. The hotel is also within close proximity to several attractions, including the Emlen Physick Estate (1.4 km), the Nature Center of Cape May (3.2 km), and the Cape May Lighthouse (5.5 km).

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

5. La Mer Beachfront Resort

8.5 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Located at the Jersey Shore in Cape May, the La Mer Beachfront Inn is one of the best hotels in the area. This boutique hotel offers guests a variety of amenities, such as free Wi-Fi, an outdoor heated pool, a business center, and a 24-hour fitness center. Guests can also take advantage of the hotel’s laundry facilities.

The rooms at the La Mer Beachfront Inn are spacious and well-appointed. Each room includes a balcony, a flat-screen cable TV, a microwave, and a refrigerator. Select rooms offer stunning ocean views. The hotel is also conveniently located just a 4-minute drive away from the Cape May city center and the Washington Street Mall. The La Mer Beachfront Inn is a great choice for travelers looking for the best hotels in Cape May.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

6. Montreal Beach Resort

8.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Montreal Beach Resort in Cape May, New Jersey, is one of the best places to stay in the area. Located just a short walk from the historic district, the resort boasts a variety of amenities, such as an outdoor pool, an on-site bar and restaurant, and a gym. All rooms have cable TV, a coffee maker, and a refrigerator; select suites offer a separate bedroom and a kitchenette.

For those wishing to explore the local area, there are plenty of attractions within a short distance of the resort. The Turdo Vineyards and Winery is 8 km away, and a carriage ride is also available nearby. The Washington Street Mall is less than one kilometer away, making it the ideal spot for some shopping. With so much to do, the Montreal Beach Resort is one of the best places to stay in Cape May, New Jersey.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

7. The Virginia and Cottages

8.9 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Virginia and Cottages is a boutique hotel in Cape May, New Jersey, located in the historic district. This 1879 restored building offers guests exclusive access to the beach and amenities such as free WiFi, minibar, and flat-screen cable TV in each room. Valet parking is available for hotel guests.

For added convenience, bathrobes are included in each room, and a safety deposit box is also provided. A continental breakfast is served daily at The Virginia and Cottages. The Ebbitt Room restaurant serves American Cuisine for dinner during the season. It is open during limited times in the off-season.

The Virginia and Cottages is conveniently located near Congress Hall, which is only 183 m away. Guests can also use the swimming pools at Congress Hall. Emlen Physick Estate is one kilometer away. This boutique hotel in Cape May is an ideal destination for travelers seeking a unique experience.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

8. Elaine’s Cape May Boutique Hotel

8.2 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Elaine’s Cape May is one of the top-rated hotels in Cape May, NJ. It offers free WiFi and is conveniently located near popular attractions such as Cape May Convention Hall, Emlen Physick Estate, and the Colonial House Museum. All of Elaine’s Cape May rooms have a flat-screen TV and a private bathroom with a bath or shower. Some rooms also have a seating area.

The hotel also features an on-site restaurant called The Porch. It serves American cuisine for breakfast and dinner and features a patio bar and live music in season until Labor Day. Other nearby attractions include the Nature Center of Cape May and Cape Island Marina, both 2.8 km away. The nearest airport is Atlantic City International Airport, 70.8 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

9. The Mason Cottage Downtown

9.2 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Mason Cottage Downtown is the nicest hotel in Cape May, NJ. This accommodation offers guests free WiFi and free bike rentals. It is air-conditioned and has a seating area with a flat-screen TV and/or iPad. An à la carte or American breakfast is available.

The Mason Cottage Downtown is conveniently located near popular tourist attractions such as Cape May Public Beach, Cape May Convention Hall, and Emlen Physick Estate. The nearest airport, Atlantic City International Airport, is 69 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

10. Boarding House Cape May

9.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Boarding House Cape May is a 3-star motel in Cape May, just one kilometer from Cape May Public Beach. This motel offers a variety of amenities, such as free bikes, free private parking, a garden, a shared lounge, and free WiFi.

The motel features comfortable rooms with air conditioning, a seating area, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a safety deposit box, a private bathroom with a shower, free toiletries, and a hairdryer. Bed linen and towels are provided.

Visitors can take advantage of various activities in and around Cape May, such as cycling. Cape May Convention Hall is one kilometer away, while Wildwoods Convention Center is 12 kilometers away. The nearest airport is Atlantic City International Airport, 68 kilometers from the motel.

Cape May is a popular tourist destination, with many boutiques and shops nearby. Guests can enjoy shopping at the various boutiques in Cape May, NJ.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE