[2023 PICKS] The Best Boutique Hotels in Siesta Key

The best boutique hotels in Siesta Key place you in some of the most idyllic locations in Florida.

Siesta Key, Florida, is an ideal vacation destination for those wanting to experience a tropical paradise. With its stunning beaches, boutique hotels, and various activities, Siesta Key is the perfect place to relax and enjoy the sun and sand. Boutique hotels on Siesta Key offer the perfect blend of luxury and comfort with their unique blend of amenities and modern, chic design.

From beachfront resorts with private pools to cozy cottages, there is something for everyone on Siesta Key. With its beautiful scenery, delicious cuisine, and exciting nightlife, Siesta Key will surely provide an unforgettable vacation experience.

We hand-picked top-rated boutique hotels in Siesta Key to consider for your next getaway!

The 10 Best Siesta Key Boutique Hotels 

1. Siesta Key Palms Resort

8.7 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Siesta Key Palms Resort is a boutique hotel in Sarasota, just 1.7 miles from Siesta Key Public Beach. It features two outdoor pools, on-site barbecue facilities, free private parking, and free WiFi throughout the resort. Guests can also take advantage of bike rentals, a yoga and activity deck, a fire pit with Tiki torches, and a guest launderette.

The guestrooms offer coffee-making facilities, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a private bathroom with a shower, free toiletries, and a hairdryer. Select accommodation also includes a seating area and kitchen.

The Ringling Museum is 15.4 km away, Siesta Key is 3.3 km away, Sarasota is 9 km away, Sarasota Bradenton Airport is 16 km away, and Selby Gardens are 5.4 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

2. The Residences on Siesta Key Beach

9.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Residences on Siesta Key Beach is a luxurious boutique hotel in Sarasota, Florida. It is 2.6 km away from Siesta Key Public Beach and 3.6 km from Siesta Key. Free private parking is available on-site.

The hotel features air-conditioned units with a seating and dining area, a kitchen with a dishwasher, and free WiFi. A spa bath is also included in each accommodation.

Hyatt Siesta Key Beach, A Hyatt Residence Club Sarasota, also provides guests with a hot tub, a fitness center, barbecue facilities, and a game area with shuffleboard and ping pong.

The hotel is 10 km away from Sarasota and 15 km from John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art. The nearest airport is Sarasota Bradenton Airport, located 16 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

3. Art Ovation Hotel, Autograph Collection

8.9 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Art Ovation Hotel, Autograph Collection is a boutique hotel in Downtown Sarasota. It is only 5 km away from the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art. Guests can enjoy free WiFi, a 50-inch flat-screen TV with Netflix and Hulu, an in-room tablet, and a small refrigerator. A Nespresso coffee machine, a private bathroom with a bath or shower, and free toiletries are also included.

The hotel has a year-round outdoor pool and a fitness center. Guests can use complimentary bicycles and a shuttle (within 4.8 km) to Downtown Sarasota, St. Armand’s Circle, and Lido Beach. Overture Restaurant and Gallery Lounge serves American fare with simple blends, fresh ingredients, and artistic presentation. Perspective Rooftop Pool Bar offers private poolside cabanas, seating, and cafe fare with a bay and city view.

Various activities such as golfing and cycling can be enjoyed in the surroundings. The Sarasota Bradenton Airport is 6 km from the boutique hotel. Quarterly curated exhibitions, performances, and special guest appearances are also available.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

4. La Mia Casa

10.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

La Mia Casa is a luxurious boutique hotel in Sarasota, Florida. Featuring a spa bath and air-conditioned accommodations, guests can enjoy complimentary WiFi and private parking available on-site.

The villa is equipped with two bedrooms, one bathroom, bed linen, towels, a flat-screen TV with streaming services, a dining area, a fully equipped kitchen, and a terrace with inner courtyard views. A continental breakfast is available daily.

Additional amenities include an outdoor fireplace and bike tours in the surrounding area. Located 12 km from The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art and 6 km from Sarasota Opera and Marina Jack Restaurant and Marina, La Mia Casa is also 12 km from Sarasota Bradenton International Airport.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

5. Lido Beach Resort – Sarasota

8.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Situated on the beautiful Lido Key, the Lido Beach Resort is a luxurious boutique hotel that offers 91 meters of private beachfront. It provides free shuttle services to St. Armands Circle and features complimentary WiFi in every room.

Each guest room is equipped with a microwave, refrigerator, and coffee machine. Some rooms have a fully-equipped kitchenette, and some suites offer a stunning beach view.

The resort also boasts two beachfront pools, a family pool, and an adults-only pool, as well as three hot tubs, a fitness center, and the Beachside Tiki Bar.

The resort is conveniently located near Central Sarasota and Sarasota Jungle Gardens, both less than 9 kilometers away. The Mote Marine Laboratory is just 3.3 kilometers away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

6. Captiva Beach Resort (open private beach access)

8.9 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Captiva Beach Resort is a boutique hotel on Siesta Key, a barrier island near Sarasota. Just two minutes’ walk from Crescent Beach, the resort offers free WiFi and an outdoor pool. Guests can also access beach towels, barbecue facilities, and games like table tennis, cornhole, badminton, and bocce ball.

The suites at Captiva Beach Resort feature a seating area, cable TV, and a sofa bed. Select suites include a kitchenette or full kitchen, and guests can request a light cleaning service or optional towel exchange.

The resort is conveniently located just 19.2 km from Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, 6.4 km from Westfield Sarasota Square Mall, and 24 minutes’ drive from Interstate 75. Guests can also enjoy the exotic wildlife of Sarasota Jungle Gardens, located 16 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

7. Hibiscus Suites – Sarasota

8.6 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Located in Sarasota, the Hibiscus Suites Inn is a boutique hotel offering one- and two-bedroom suites with fully equipped kitchens, separate seating areas, and sofa beds. Guests can enjoy cable TV, free Wi-Fi, and a private entrance. The hotel also features an outdoor pool on a garden terrace open year-round.

The Hibiscus Suites Inn is conveniently located just 2 miles from the Siesta Key Public Beach and 5 miles from Interstate 75. It is also 10 miles from the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art and 12 miles from the Myakka River State Park. On-site parking is free, and the hotel also offers free Wi-Fi.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

8. Tropical Breeze Resort

8.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Tropical Breeze Resort is a luxurious boutique hotel in Sarasota, Florida, just 529 meters from the famous Siesta Beach. This hotel spans two city blocks and offers guests two heated on-site pools, a spa, and complimentary shuttle service around Siesta Key.

Each room of this boutique hotel includes a microwave and refrigerator, free WiFi, and cable TV. Select rooms also feature a full kitchen. For added convenience, four launderettes are located on-site, as well as a sun terrace.

Tropical Breeze Resort is just a 5-minute walk from Siesta Beach and 9 km from the Marie Selby Botanical Gardens. It is also 14.3 km from the Sarasota Jungle Gardens and 20 minutes drive from the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art. Mote Marine Laboratory and Aquarium is 15 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

9. Whitewood

8.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Whitewood is a boutique hotel in Siesta Key, just 300 meters from Crescent Beach. This stylish accommodation offers guests a variety of amenities, including free WiFi, free private parking, a sun terrace, and barbecue facilities with views of the pool.

The hotel’s rooms are air-conditioned and feature a seating area, a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, a kitchenette, a dining area, and a private bathroom with free toiletries, a shower, and a hairdryer. Bed linen and towels are provided in every room.

Nearby attractions include Turtle Beach, located 1.7 km away. The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art is 18 km away, and Marina Jack Restaurant and Marina, 12 km away. Sarasota Bradenton International Airport is 18 km from the hotel.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

10. Hotel Indigo – Sarasota, an IHG Hotel 

8.5 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Hotel Indigo Sarasota is a luxurious boutique hotel that offers free shuttle services to and from Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport, which is 3.7 miles away. It boasts an on-site restaurant and spacious rooms with a flat-screen TV and free Wi-Fi.

The rooms at this boutique hotel are decorated with bright colors, hardwood floors, and unique wall murals. All rooms come with a work desk and bathroom amenities.

The on-site restaurant, H2O Bistro and Lounge, serves modern American cuisine and a full bar menu. Guests can also work out in the gym, relax in the outdoor hot tubs, and take advantage of the business center’s fax/copy services. Parking is free, and an electric car charging station is available onsite.

Hotel Indigo Sarasota is close to many attractions, such as Lido Beach, 3.5 miles away, and Ringling Museum of Art, 3 miles away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE