[2023 PICKS] The Best Boutique Hotels in Long Island, New York

The best boutique hotels in Long Island place you in some of the most idyllic locations in this picturesque town.

Long Island is popular for its sandy beaches, historic sites, and charming towns. Visitors can explore the famous beaches of the Hamptons, visit the Montauk Lighthouse, or take a trip to Fire Island National Seashore to enjoy the area’s natural beauty. The island also offers a variety of shopping, dining, and nightlife options, as well as a range of outdoor activities like hiking and fishing. Long Island is also home to several historic sites, including the Vanderbilt Mansion and the Old Westbury Gardens. With so much to see and do, Long Island is the perfect destination for a weekend getaway or a longer vacation.

We hand-picked top-rated boutique hotels in Long Island to consider for your next getaway!

The 10 Best Long Island Boutique Hotels – Places to Stay on Long Island

1. Topping Rose House

7.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Located in Bridgehampton, Topping Rose House is one of the finest boutique hotels in Long Island that offers luxury accommodation featuring a flat-screen TV, an iPad, a minibar, and a sitting area. The en suite bathroom has a hairdryer, and guests can enjoy the luxury of Frette linens and bathrobes.

On-site amenities include a spa, an outdoor heated pool, a fitness center, a curated art collection, and free WiFi access. The hotel also offers a complimentary shuttle to the beach, private beach passes, and complimentary house vehicles provided by Lexus for guests to use.

Additionally, the on-site restaurant serves locally sourced ingredients and products from the hotel’s own one-acre farm and serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

2. Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

7.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Gurney’s Montauk is a boutique hotel on Long Island located directly on the beach and provides year-round accommodation in Montauk, 13.4 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. All rooms feature a flat-screen cable TV, a private bathroom with a hairdryer, and free WiFi access.

Guests can enjoy a full-service spa, five dining and drinking venues, and a 24-hour front desk. Hither Hills State Park is 3.7 km away, and Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 6.9 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

3. Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

8.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

This New York hotel is one of the best choices for Long Island boutique hotels that is near the Westbury Music Fair and features a Zen-inspired full-service spa. This feng shui hotel offers on-site dining and spacious rooms with free Wi-Fi.

A flat-screen cable TV and iPod dock are offered in every Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham room. Each includes natural décor, a microwave, and a refrigerator. The full marble bathrooms include bathrobes and amenities.

Guests can relax by massage, sit in the sauna, or swim in the indoor pool at Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham. A beauty salon is also located at the hotel.

Marco Polo’s restaurant serves Italian and Asian cuisine. It has a full-service bar and an adults-only game room.

Cantiague Park is 2.7 km from the hotel. Broadway Mall Shopping Center is 4.2 km away. The NYCB Theatre at Westbury is 650 m from the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

4. Garden City Hotel

8.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Garden City Hotel is considered by many as one of the best boutique hotels on Long Island, featuring 272 guest rooms and suites. Each room has custom millwork and Italian furniture, plush pillow top mattresses, mini refrigerators, bathrooms with French boutique amenities, and technology for connecting all mobile devices. The penthouse rooms and suites also boast balconies that overlook the village of Garden City.

The hotel provides a 24-hour fitness center, an indoor pool from 7 AM to 7 PM, a seasonal outdoor dining area, and a Patio Bar, which serves refreshing cocktails. The on-site restaurants, Red Salt Room by David Burke and King Bar by David Burke, offer steaks, chops, signature entrées, a bar menu, scratch-made cocktails, and an extensive wine list. Guests have easy access to New York City and its major airports via the Long Island Railroad, located across from the hotel.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

5. Journey East Hampton

8.1 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Journey East Hampton is located in East Hampton, 1.8 km from Indian Wells Beach, Two Mile Hollow Beach, and Egypt Beach. This boutique hotel on Long Island offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden, a shared lounge, and free WiFi. The rooms come with a wardrobe, flat-screen TV, air conditioning, a private bathroom with a shower and free toiletries, and some rooms have a seating area.

Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast every morning, and the hotel is non-smoking. Nearby attractions include the Montauk Point Lighthouse, 11 km away. Second House Museum and Hither Woods Preserve are 20 km away, and the nearest airport, Long Island MacArthur Airport, is 85 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

6. Southampton Inn

8.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

This Long Island hotel is one of the best hotels in Long Island, situated on over 5 acres of beautifully landscaped lawns. It features a modern American restaurant, Claude’s, with poolside service and provides free summer transportation to Cooper’s Beach. The rooms at the Southampton Inn have seashore themes with free WiFi, cable TV, a refrigerator, and a work desk.

Guests can enjoy the outdoor pool, tennis court, library, games room, and children’s play area. The Inn is less than 4 km from Southampton Golf Course and less than 15 km from the Morton National Wildlife Refuge.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

7. Baron’s Cove

8.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Baron’s Cove is situated in Sag Harbor, New York, and features an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool. Free WiFi is accessible throughout the property, and free private parking is available on-site. Each guest room has a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator, and the private bathrooms include bathrobes and free toiletries. Select rooms offer views of the sea or garden.

Guests at Baron’s Cove are greeted at the 24-hour front desk, and clothing, accessories, and refreshments are available at The Dock Shop. The dining room serves fresh American cuisine and is open daily for lunch and dinner, offering breakfast and brunch on the weekends. Bike hire is available at this hotel, and the area is popular for cycling. Mystic is 48 km away, while Montauk is 29 km away, and the nearest airport is Stewart International Airport, 73 km from the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

8. The Montauk Beach House

8.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Montauk Beach House is conveniently located just off Route 27 and offers an outdoor swimming pool, gift shop, café, and snack bar. Each air-conditioned guest room features a flat-screen cable TV and a private bathroom with free toiletries; some rooms have a pool view. Guests can relax poolside or enjoy cocktails in the lounge, and there is a DJ on-site every weekend. The gift shop sells clothing, beauty products, and more.

A 24-hour front desk, a café, and an outdoor grill serving small plates and sandwiches. Further dining options, such as South Edison, can be found within walking distance. Free Wi-Fi access is available throughout the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

9. Haven Montauk

8.6 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Haven Montauk is situated in Montauk, within 9.5 km of Gin Beach and 5.5 km of Theodore Roosevelt County Park. It provides accommodation with free bikes, a garden, and free WiFi. Guests can enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool, a fire pit, a barbecue area, and beach parking passes.

The bay is a 4-minute’ walk across the street from the property, Montauk Downs State Park is 3.4 km away, and Montauk Point State Park is 8.8 km away. Montauk Racquet Club is 3.7 km away, Navy Park Road is 5 km from the hotel, and Montauk train station is 3.2 km away. Block Island Ferry is 300 m away.

All rooms in the hotel are fitted with a TV and a wardrobe and have a private bathroom, while some rooms include a kitchenette. Some rooms view the ocean, and some view Lake Montauk and the sunset.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

10. Fathoms Hotel & Marina

9.7 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Fathoms Hotel & Marina is located in Port Washington, 18 km from Belmont Park Race Track. It offers accommodation featuring a garden, free private parking, a shared lounge, a terrace, a bar, and non-smoking rooms. Each room has a seating area, a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, a private bathroom with free toiletries and a shower, bed linen, towels, and a balcony. Guests can enjoy a continental breakfast.

The property is 19 km from Citi Field, 21 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, 22 km from Arthur Ashe Stadium, and 28 km from Aqueduct Racetrack. LaGuardia Airport is the nearest airport, 20 km from Fathoms Hotel & Marina.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE