[2023 PICKS] The Best Boutique Hotels in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts

The best boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard place you in some of the most idyllic locations in Massachusetts.

Martha’s Vineyard is a picturesque island located just off the coast of Massachusetts, making it an ideal travel destination for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of the city. Known for its quaint towns, scenic beaches, and rich cultural history, Martha’s Vineyard has something to offer for every type of traveler. From relaxing on the sandy shores to exploring the island’s unique shops and restaurants, visitors can immerse themselves in the island’s natural beauty and vibrant community.

With a laid-back atmosphere and stunning scenery, Martha’s Vineyard is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a tranquil and authentic New England experience.

We hand-picked top-rated boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard to consider for your next getaway!

The 10 Best Martha’s Vineyard Boutique Hotels – Best Places to Stay

1. The Sydney

8.9 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Martha’s Vineyard is home to many boutique hotels, and The Sydney is a notable example. Located just 150 m from Edgartown Harbor and the ferry to Falmouth, this inn provides guests free WiFi access. It features non-smoking rooms with air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, in-room ironing facilities, an en suite bathroom with bathrobes, free toiletries, and a hairdryer. The Sydney also offers self-check-in/check-out and boasts an on-site garden and patio where guests can relax in the Victorian surroundings.

L’Etoile is the on-site restaurant at The Sydney, which serves dinner nightly as well as breakfast baskets delivered each morning between 8:00 and 8:15. These baskets include fresh fruit, orange juice, coffee, overnight oats, a curated egg dish, and homemade sweet and savory pastries. With its charming restaurant (L’Etorestaurantile), convenient location close to all amenities of Martha’s Vineyard Island, and luxurious accommodation facilities provided, Sydney is certainly one of the most favored boutique hotels on Martha’s Vineyard.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

2. Ashley Inn

8.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

One of the best places to stay in Martha’s Vineyard is The Ashley Inn; it is located in central Edgartown, only 1.6 km away from the Edgartown Lighthouse. The inn features guest rooms with individual designs, antique furniture, en suite bathrooms and cable TV. Guests also have access to a common living area filled with books, as well as an outdoor hammock for relaxation.

The Seafood Shanty Restaurant, which is only a short walk away from the inn, offers free WiFi access and has a beautiful garden patio ideal for outdoor dining or lounging. Other nearby attractions include Joseph Sylvia State Beach (5 km) and South Beach (5km), as well as the Edgartown Golf Club (800m) – all within driving distance of The Ashley Inn.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

3. Pequot Hotel

8.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

4. Summercamp

8.6 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

If you’re looking for the best places to stay in Martha’s Vineyard, consider Summercamp. This historic boutique hotel is located in Oak Bluffs and offers guests stunning oceanfront views.

It also features a variety of amenities, including a game room and common lounging areas, and is just steps away from the beach. The property has been renovated to contain modern amenities such as iPads loaded with area information, USB charging outlets, smart TVs with Apple TV, a camp canteen with snacks, and complimentary toiletries for added comfort.

Summercamp also provides free WiFi and daily housekeeping services, making it an ideal destination for guests who want to relax in a convenient environment. Guests can find nearby dining options within walking distance of the hotel, while longer distances activities like the Farm Neck Golf Club are only 3.7 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

5. The Edgartown Inn

9.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The best hotel in Martha’s Vineyard is Summercamp in Oak Bluffs. The hotel has been renovated from the 1879 property and offers oceanfront views. It features modern amenities such as smart TVs with Apple TVs, USB charging outlets, and radios. Rooms also come with complimentary robes and toiletries; some rooms include seating areas or refrigerators.

At Summercamp, you will find a game room and common lounging areas for your enjoyment. Guests can access iPads with area information, hospitality centers, free Wi-Fi throughout the property, camp canteen snacks, and a 24-hour front desk available for service. Coffee makers are also provided to suite guests and cottage suites. In addition to all of these services, daily housekeeping services are offered free of charge.

Summercamp is situated 3.7 km away from Farm Neck Golf Club, with several dining options nearby. The property is also only a 5-minute walk from Oak Bluffs Ferry, making it easy for guests to explore many parts of Martha’s Vineyard.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

6. The Richard

9.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Richard is one of the best Martha’s Vineyard boutique hotels, located in Edgartown that offers free WiFi to guests, ensuring that they have access to high-speed internet during their stay.

All rooms at The Richard are equipped with a flat-screen TV with cable channels and a private bathroom, providing guests with modern amenities to enhance their comfort and convenience.

A grab-and-go continental breakfast is available daily at The Richard, providing guests with a convenient and tasty option to start their day. This breakfast option allows guests to quickly grab a bite to eat before heading out to explore the surrounding area or attend to their daily activities.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

7. Harbor View Hotel

9.1 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Harbor View Hotel and Resort is one of the most sought-after Martha’s Vineyard boutique hotels. Located just 10 minutes away by foot from the downtown area of Edgartown, hotel guests can enjoy marvellous views of the Edgartown Lighthouse from their rooms.

This charming boutique hotel offers a range of amenities to ensure an enjoyable stay including an on-site restaurant and two bars, cable TV, free Wi-Fi, a refrigerator, safety deposit box and even sailing lessons. For those preferring to stay put in their room, room service is available during certain seasons.

Other facilities for guests to take advantage of include an outdoor pool and concierge services – handy for planning out your days while in the area. The Martha’s Vineyard airport can be reached within 15 minutes by car and if you’re feeling active then the Edgartown Golf Club is just five minutes away from the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

8. Faraway Martha’s Vineyard

8.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Faraway Martha’s Vineyard is a boutique hotel located in Martha’s Vineyard, only a 5-minute walk from Edgartown Harbor. This hotel features a restaurant, pub, and outdoor pool to provide guests with various options for dining and recreation during their stay.

Guest rooms have modern amenities such as free Wi-Fi, cable TV, seating areas, desks, coffee makers, refrigerators, safety deposit boxes, and bathrobes. The hotel has two on-site restaurants and an open seasonally poolside bar called the Newes from America Pub, which serves American and British cuisine year-round.

In addition to this hotel amenity, the Edgartown Golf Club is located just one kilometer away. Moreover, South Beach State Park is 4.8 km away. In comparison, Martha’s Vineyard Airport is 8 km from the hotel, making it easily accessible to guests who are both arriving or departing from Boutique Hotel in Martha’s Vineyard.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

9. Hob Knob

9.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Hob Knob is one of the best boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard. It offers an unforgettable stay with its wrap-around porch, on-site spa, and proximity to Joseph Sylvia State Beach—just 4.8 km away. Each guest room is decorated classically in light colors with plush bedding, equipped with a flat-screen cable TV, free Wi-Fi access, a refrigerator, bathrobes, and natural bath amenities.

The hotel also offers luxurious spa services for complete relaxation: guests can book massage sessions and access to the state-of-the-art fitness center and steam room. To make the most of their stay, guests can enjoy a full breakfast and afternoon tea in the lush garden and take advantage of On-Site Concierge Services—including dining arrangements, vineyard excursions, and bike rentals.

With all these features combined, it’s easy to see why The Hob Knob is a top choice for luxury boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

10. Lambert’s Cove Inn & Resort

8.2 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Boutique hotels in Martha’s Vineyard offer visitors a special lodging experience. Lambert’s Cove Inn & Resort is located in West Tivsbury and is conveniently located near popular attractions and transportation links. Visitors can enjoy complimentary WiFi and free private parking during their stay.

Rooms are complete with flat-screen TVs, DVD players, a seating zone, and private bathrooms, including complimentary bath robes and toiletries. The hotel also provides a shared lounge area and bike and car hire services for convenience. In the surrounding area, guests can visit Lambert’s Cove Beach, 1.4 km away, or Old House Pond, 550 m away from the hotel.

Those traveling by airplane can use Martha’s Vineyard Airport, just 6 km away, or take the ferries with Vineyard Heaven Ferry Terminal, 8.5 km away, and Oak Bluffs Ferry Terminal, 13.1 km away from the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE