[2023 PICKS] The Best Boutique Hotels in The Hamptons

The best boutique hotels in The Hamptons place you in some of the most idyllic locations in New York.

The Hamptons, located on the eastern end of Long Island, New York, is a world-renowned travel destination that attracts visitors from all over the globe. It is a collection of small, picturesque towns and villages nestled alongside miles of stunning beaches, sprawling estates, and farmland.

The area is well-known for its celebrity sightings, designer boutiques, exquisite dining experiences, and luxurious beachfront homes.

We hand-picked top-rated boutique hotels in The Hamptons to consider for your next getaway!

The 10 The Hamptons Boutique Hotels – Best Places to Stay

1. Montauk Manor

8.6 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Montauk Manor is considered by travelers as one of the best boutique hotels in the Hamptons. It features on-site spa services, an indoor and outdoor swimming pool, and free Wi-Fi access.

Each uniquely decorated room has air conditioning, cable TV, and a seating area. It also has a full kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave and a private bathroom with free toiletries.

The spa and wellness center and multiple tennis courts are available for guests. Meeting facilities and luggage storage are also offered. From horse riding and fishing to a complimentary electric car charger, there is an array of activities to enjoy on-site or in the surroundings.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

2. The Menhaden Hotel

9.4 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Menhaden Hotel is located in Greenport, and offers 4-star accommodation. Guests can enjoy the terrace and bar onsite. There is also a 24-hour front desk, concierge service, and luggage storage for guests.

Each room in this boutique hotel in the Hamptons is air-conditioned and has a private bathroom, flat-screen TV, free WiFi, and free toiletries. There is also a wardrobe in every room.

The nearest airport to the hotel is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 76 km away. Splish Splash is 41 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

3. Baron’s Cove

8.3 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Located in Sag Harbor, New York, Baron’s Cove is one of Hampton’s boutique hotels. It offers a variety of amenities, including an on-site restaurant, a seasonal saltwater swimming pool, free WiFi, and free private parking. Each guest room is equipped with a flat-screen cable TV, a refrigerator, and a private bathroom with bathrobes and complimentary toiletries. Some rooms feature views of the sea or garden.

At the 24-hour front desk, guests of Baron’s Cove are welcomed. The Dock Shop provides clothing, accessories, and refreshments. The dining room serves American cuisine daily for lunch and dinner, and breakfast and brunch are served on the weekends. Additionally, bike hire is available, and the area is popular for cycling. Mystic is 48 km away, and Montauk is 29 km from the hotel.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

4. The Pridwin Hotel

8.7 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Located on Shelter Island, the Pridwin is a waterfront resort designed for couples, friends, and families. It offers 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages. Guests can enjoy the all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views, the full-service spa, the scenic pool, and seasonal activities for every age.

The surrounding area is perfect for exploring the idyllic natural setting through hiking, boating, and other outdoor activities. After a day of exploring, guests can retreat to the comfort of the private suites and cottages.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

5. Journey East Hampton

8.1 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Journey East Hampton is located in East Hampton, 1.8 km from Indian Wells Beach and Two Mile Hollow Beach. The hotel offers accommodation, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden, and a shared lounge. It is also 11 km away from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Free WiFi is available.

This Hampton boutique hotel has non-smoking rooms equipped with a wardrobe, a private bathroom with a shower and free toiletries, a flat-screen TV, air conditioning, and, in some rooms, a seating area. Bed linen and towels are provided.

A continental breakfast is served daily.

Nearby places of interest include the Second House Museum (20 km) and Hither Woods Preserve (20 km). The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 85 km from the property.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

6. The Quogue Club

9.1 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Quogue Club is set in Quogue, 39 km from East Hampton. It features air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, an on-site bar, and free private parking.

All rooms have a flat-screen TV with cable channels, a private bathroom, bathrobes, free toiletries, and a hairdryer.

At the boutique hotel, guests will find a 24-hour front desk. Guests can also enjoy tennis or golf, arranged through a partnership with Westhampton Racquet Club and Laurel Links Golf Club, or go cycling in the area, with free use of bicycles provided by the hotel.

Riverhead is 12 km away, while Greenport is 38 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

7. Rams Head Inn

9.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

The Rams Head Inn is one of the Hamptons boutique hotels on Shelter Island. It offers a variety of amenities to its guests, including a garden, terrace, restaurant, and bar. It also provides a buffet or continental breakfast and a children’s playground.

Guests can take advantage of the private beach area and participate in water sports. Additionally, there are plenty of nearby activities, such as hiking, for guests to enjoy.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

8. EHP Resort

8.8 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

EHP Resort is located in East Hampton, New York. It is situated 7 km from Atlantic Avenue Beach. The resort offers a seasonal outdoor pool, children’s playground, free WiFi, and free private parking.

The rooms feature a flat-screen TV, seating area, terrace or patio, and private bathroom. Bathrobes and free toiletries are available for guests’ comfort.

The resort also has a seasonal restaurant open from the 28th of May until the 4th of September.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

9. Historic White Blossom House

8.5 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Historic White Blossom House is a uniquely furnished inn located in Southold. It features scenic gardens, patio access, and free parking. The self-catering apartment includes a kitchenette equipped with an oven, a dishwasher, and a bathroom with free toiletries.

Guests are offered free bike hire and free WiFi access. Various activities are available, such as golfing and cycling, both on-site and in the local area.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE

10. Sound View Greenport

8.0 Average Rating
Get the Lowest Rates Here

Sound View Greenport is located on the North Fork in Greenport, 157 km from New York City. It features a seasonal outdoor pool, views of the Long Island Sound, and a bar. All the rooms are waterfront and include a seating area, a private bathroom with a bath or shower, free toiletries, and a hair dryer.

There is also a shared lounge, private beach area, and bike hire available. Guests can play tennis at the property, and Montauk is 38 km away, while East Hampton is 23 km away.

GET THE LOWEST RATES HERE